top of page
Search

Culture War: A Scandurro Story

Nov 9
7 min read

BY TIM SCANDURRO


I spoke to a Tulane fan before Homecoming this past Saturday who pointed out that Coach Fritz and Coach Sumrall had squeaked by bad teams too, and nobody gave them the grief Will Hall has gotten for doing the same.  I told him one big difference was that those coaches would also spank teams convincingly from time to time, and what we needed desperately was a blowout game.

 

Well, we got one.  I suppose the lesson is to be careful what you wish for, or at least be very specific when you make the wish.    Our team was not prepared emotionally, physically or schematically to play this football game.  On the other sideline, Tulsa looked like a team should look coming off a bye week.  They were crisp in their execution and they played like the more physical and athletic team all day.   On offense their quarterback was confident, accurate and in complete control of the game, and their receivers outclassed our secondary from start to finish.

 

On the other side of the ball our quarterback, in whom we have placed so much hope, was hit early and turned uncharacteristically indecisive and inaccurate.  Tulsa ran simple stunts up front that our offensive line struggled to identify all game long, when they weren’t simply getting whipped man on man physically.  Our new play caller, whom we also thought would bring improved results, had no answers and spent a lot of time in the second half staring at his call sheet, looking like me trying to read a menu in a dark restaurant.   “How do I turn the flashlight on and where are my reading glasses?”  It was ugly.

 

Through the first eight games of uneven and concerning performances, the one thing you could say going into Saturday was that the team had hung together spiritually and played hard for each other. 

 

You can’t say that this week, not with any conviction.  Tulsa brought the game to us from the opening snap, and we never punched back.  In a program that is supposed to be built on “attitude is everything,” one that is supposed to see adversity as opportunity, the lack of fight on both sides of the ball was more than just disheartening.  It was, as Coach Hall admitted afterwards, humiliating.  We’re all embarrassed and we should be.

 

The result was particularly painful because Saturday was one of those Chamber of Commerce mornings in New Orleans, the kind of day when you wake up and are glad to be alive.  The stage was set on a sun-splashed gorgeous Homecoming day and in front of throngs of visiting alumni decked out in Tulane gear.  Mike Fitts and his Board could not possibly have asked for anything better, right up until 11:01 AM CST.

 

 

All of the optimistic narratives collapsed or were seriously damaged in one regrettable afternoon.   This was not Ole Miss spanking us twice last year, or Ohio State and Oklahoma beating us badly under Coach Fritz. This was Tulsa, a smaller school in our own league with a smaller budget who whipped us worse than any of those opponents did.  And this one, unlike those, was at home.

 

Defensive end Jah'rie Garner said a couple of interesting and very honest things at the podium after the game.  He said he told his defensive teammates in the second half that “even though we’re not scoring and stopping them, you still got to go out and play.  If we don’t go out there, nobody else will…..it can be easy to say forget the season, people are going to make decisions…but we’re all we got.” 

 

‘People are going to make decisions.’ There it is, the thing that so many college coaches have stood behind so many podiums and complained about.  In an era of unlimited transfers and pay for play, it ain’t like it used to be. When an NFL defensive back decides not to get in the way of a battering ram like Derrick Henry, you’ll hear an announcer say ‘he made a business decision.’  When a player under contract refuses to report to practice because he wants his deal renegotiated, you’ll hear ‘well that’s just business.  He needs to take care of himself and his family while he can.’

 

In the NFL you can demand a release and sometimes a team will give you one, but the team holds the cards.  In college football today with unlimited transfers and player parents and families much more heavily involved, not so much.

 

And so team goals are always going to be in tension with individual goals, even in good times.  But the tension is always going to grow stronger when adversity strikes, team goals fade and players start making plans that don’t involve their current teammates.

 

To be clear, I don’t know that any of this is going on here the way it has at other places, and even if it is the staff is ultimately answerable for all of it.  Almost every coach will tell you the system is broken, but blaming the players never works and a coach who does that needs to point at himself first. 

 

I’m just doing the simple math here.  60-10 against Tulsa, with the personnel we have and the personnel they have, adds up to problems that go well beyond poor game plans or poor execution. I don’t care if this is ‘a new era’.  Effort in practice and games and attention to detail and respect for your teammates and coaches, enforced by the team and the staff from top to bottom, have to be nonnegotiable.  Otherwise nothing will work. 

 

The Apple Effect.  When Willie Fritz got here, I remember him telling me a story about our top returning wide receiver who showed up at his office with his ‘representation.’ This was pre-NIL, a time when players didn’t have agents like they do today.  This player’s ‘agent’ was a former college star from the neighborhood, who told Coach Fritz his ‘client’ was concerned about the run-heavy offense Fritz planned to run and how that might affect the receiver’s ‘touches.’  Fritz told me he listened politely and then told the player he might be better off transferring somewhere else with his blessing. The player did.  Fritz didn’t want him in his locker room, no matter how talented he was.

 

I can’t remember if Fritz said this or someone else did, but it always stuck with me:   ‘A bad apple won’t spoil the whole barrel.  But it will spoil the other apples that it’s touching.’  I always assumed that quote came originally from a football coach, but it actually traces back to the 14th Century and was later popularized by Benjamin Franklin when he wrote “the rotten apple spoils his companion.”

 

When my younger daughter was in grade school, I remember her complaining about a group project.  “It’s not fair,” she said.  “Why should everybody in the group get an “A” grade when I’m doing most of the work?”  And there’s the rub.  Weaker teammates may be poisoned by the bad apples, but even dedicated team members, the ones doing things the right way, can see their motivation wane when other players decide to drop the rope.  Fictional coach Tony D’Amato said it best:  a good teammate sacrifices himself for the team “because he knows when it comes down to it, you’re going to do the same for him.  That’s a team, gentlemen. And either we heal, as a team, or we will die as individuals.”

 

That team-first sacrifice has been our culture for several years now, but if you didn’t see signs of water coming through the dam on Saturday you weren’t paying close enough attention.  Professional bettors certainly are.  They have no time or tolerance for faith and hope narratives.  They are cold and data-driven.  So now we go on the road to face a 1-8 Rice team that is 0-5 in conference play, and Vegas has installed the Owls as a favorite. 

 

If you want a sliver of hope, a small ray of sunshine, take a look at the post-game interview of backup quarterback Dagan Bruno who led a late drive and threw a touchdown pass with one second left on the clock.  Without that score, this would have been the worst home loss suffered by Tulane since 1958.  I wasn’t born yet, but for you older Tulanians, I don’t have to tell you who that one was against, or what the final score was. 

 

Bruno said he was proud of the heart and fight that his teammates showed on that last drive.  Our beat reporter asked him what the halftime locker room was like, considering the cause was so hopeless down 32-0 (I really wish he had asked that question to vintage Jim Mora).  Bruno said that if Tulsa had scored 32 points in the first half, he believed we could do so in the second.    He said veteran guys who he named stepped up and got vocal.  It didn’t work, but the conviction was still there….at least for a group of our players.

 

“We need to coach better and we need to play better” was about as specific as Will Hall got in his post-mortem after the game.  And we have no chance of beating 1-8 Rice unless both of those things happen.  But the far bigger battle this week has nothing to do with X’s and O’s.   It’s a culture war this week.  It’s about those who still care about investing themselves in this football team and those who don’t, whether they are wearing headsets or helmets.  It’s about the one thing we thought we could count on in this difficult season, and it’s about the one thing we can least afford to lose.  The soul of a football team is the most important asset it has.  It’s the one intangible that makes all the tangibles possible.  We can’t surrender it without a fight.

 

 
 
 

9 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Unknown member
Nov 14
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

in 1949 Rufus Harris announced that Tulane was de-emphasizing sports. We went in to that season ranked #1 when he made that declaration. It still holds today because in the 77 years since Tulane ingrained it to its students to look down on athletics. What true big money people Tulane produced in that time don't step up like other whales at other schools to raise our program up because of the mentality that was instilled in them. We need a new president that gets the importance of athletics and what it can do for the academic side of the school. Her name is Pam Whiten an Tulane alum who is the president of Indiana University.

Like

Unknown member
Nov 10
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Thank you for the well written and sensitive article, Tim. Yes, college football ain’t what it used to be.


Now we know it only takes 9 games to lose a championship culture. How long to regain one?

Like
Unknown member
Nov 13
Replying to

Thankfully, quickly. Sumrall did that at Troy, he didn't inherit there what he inherited here. Look at New Mexico this year, as well as UCLA. The right coach can change the culture. As much as we would like to attribute the culture stemming from the name on the jersey we are proven over and over that is not the case. Even Alabama languished through Shula etc. Nebraska and Florida State are counting on ghost the lift them through. It comes from a leader in the present.

Like

Unknown member
Nov 09
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

“And so team goals are always going to be in tension with individual goals, even in good times.  But the tension is always going to grow stronger when adversity strikes, team goals fade and players start making plans that don’t involve their current teammates.”

I can’t stop thinking about this observation.

Like

Unknown member
Nov 09
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Loved the article above. Captured the moment.


I don’t agree with the comment above about donors. Tulane is moving forward in this area. The players were all in town this past weekend and they are not happy. Maybe for the first time, Gibson Hall just might take notice. The David Harris statement on Saturday night hopefully brings his era to an end. Same for Coach Hall. This was a monumental mistake. A team coming off a playoff appearance has no business hiring a coach with a losing record from a lesser football program (of course, I would argue any program). The only thing good about this new system is you can turn it around in one year. Let’s hope fo…

Like

Unknown member
Nov 09
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

We just don’t have what other schools have and that’s always been the case. Big donors don’t care, students don’t care, the community doesn’t care. Other schools that attract the same students we do (SMU, Wake Forest, Miami, Vandy) they invest and aren’t afraid to go in the red if it means building something great athletically, because they know the trickle down. Miami and SMU reinvested in sports after periods of lull and now they’re having record number of application and donors come in.

I just don’t see our admin or board ever thinking like those schools do. We barley made any major donor movement after a CFP appearance for god sake.


It a few days later and I still…

Like
  • Instagram
  • X
Fear the Wave logo

© Fear the Wave Collective

bottom of page